Subject Line SOS: Write Emails Your Subscribers Can't Help But Open

Table of Contents Show

We need to talk about your email subject lines.

I know, I know.

They might seem like just a few little words (how important could they be, right?), but here's the thing: I've learned the hard way that your subject line can literally make or break your entire email marketing strategy.

Think about it... you could write the most amazing, value-packed email ever created, but if no one clicks to open it? Well, it might as well not exist. (Harsh but true!)

Here's the good news though – writing subject lines that make people actually want to open your emails doesn't require any weird marketing tricks or pushy tactics.

I'm going to share exactly what I've learned about creating subject lines that feel personal, spark genuine interest, and drive real action... all without making you feel like you need a shower afterward. 🚿

Why Subject Lines Matter WAY More Than You Think

Let me paint you a picture... Your subject line is basically the bouncer of your email (stay with me here). It's standing there at the front of the inbox, deciding whether your email gets in to the party or gets turned away at the door.

The "Bouncer" Effect

A good subject line is like having a VIP pass – it gets you instant access. A weak one? Well, that's basically showing up in flip-flops when there's a dress code. Your email either gets deleted immediately or (possibly worse) just sits there collecting virtual dust.

Here's the Thing About Conversions...

You can't convert someone who never opens your email in the first place. (Mind-blowing, I know!) Even if your email content is pure gold, it won't matter one bit if your subject line doesn't get them to click.

The Inbox is CROWDED (Like, really crowded)

Most people get over 100 emails every single day.

If that number made you anxious, you're not alone! Your email needs to work extra hard to stand out in that sea of "Re: Following up..." messages.

The Anatomy of an Effective Subject Line

(ie What makes a subject line actually WORK?)

Spoiler alert: it's not about using fancy words or trying to sound like a marketing guru. Let's break down what really matters...

• Keep It Short (but Not TOO Short)
  Most inboxes (especially on mobile... which let's be honest, is where most of us read our email these days) cut off subject lines around 40-50 characters. I aim for 6-10 words max. Anything longer and you're just writing words no one will ever see!

• Personalization Works (But Don't Overdo It)
  Using someone's name or mentioning something specific to them can work wonders... but there's definitely a line between personalized and stalker-ish. A simple "[Name], I think you'll love this" can feel warm and friendly. "[Name], I saw you looking at red sweaters last Tuesday" feels... well, you get the idea. 😬

• Curiosity (Without Being Vague)
  People open emails because something catches their eye. Think of it like those Netflix show descriptions – you want to give them just enough to make them click, but not so much that they feel like they already know everything.

Types of Subject Lines That Perform Well

After sending approximately one zillion emails (okay, maybe slightly fewer, haha), here are the types of subject lines I've found that consistently get people clicking...

Questions That Make You Think

We all love a good question – it's like our brains can't help but want to answer them!

Try these:

• "Want to know why your emails aren't getting opened?" (Way more effective than "Tips for Better Email Marketing" right?)

• "Struggling to write subject lines? I've got you covered" (Who hasn't been there?)

Numbers and Lists

There's something so satisfying about knowing exactly what you're getting into. It's like having a menu instead of someone just saying "we have food."

Try these formats:

• "5 subject line mistakes you're (probably) making right now"

• "3 quick ways to boost your open rates this week"

FOMO & Urgency (But Please Use Responsibly!)

We've all seen those "LAST CHANCE!!!" emails that make us roll our eyes so hard they might get stuck.

But used sparingly (and honestly), a little urgency can work wonders:

• "Only 2 spots left for tomorrow's workshop..."

• "Tomorrow's the last day to grab the early bird price!"

Just Keep It Real (Sometimes Simple Wins)

Sometimes the best approach is just... telling people what's inside (revolutionary, I know):

• "Your website audit results are ready"

• "Quick question about your launch strategy"

Words and Phrases to Avoid (and Why)

Oh boy, have I made some mistakes here... Instead of "FREE FREE FREE!" (yikes), try "Download your guide." Instead of "EXCLUSIVE OFFER!" maybe go with "Just for my subscribers." You get the idea. Certain words trigger spam filters or feel overly promotional, which hurts open rates.

Avoid these:

• Spam Trigger Words
  Words like "Free," "Act Now," and "Exclusive Offer" can send your email straight to spam, do not pass go. Instead, use more neutral language like "Download Your Guide" or "Join Us for the Webinar."

• Vague Phrases
  "Check this out" or "Don't miss out" are basically the email equivalent of someone saying "trust me" – not super convincing! Be specific about what awesome value you're offering instead.

• Overly Salesy Language
  You know those emails that feel like they're screaming at you through the screen? Yeah, let's not do that. Focus on being helpful instead of... well, whatever this is: "BUY NOW BEFORE IT'S TOO LATE!!!"

---

---

How to Know If Your Subject Lines Are Actually Working

Test, Test, and Test Again (But Make It Easy)

I'm not going to tell you to create some complicated testing system – ain't nobody got time for that! Just try this simple approach (called A/B Testing):

1. Write two different subject lines

2. Send them to different parts of your list

3. See which one got more opens

4. Do more of what works!

Watch Those Numbers (But Don't Obsess)

Keep an eye on your open rates, but remember – they're just numbers. If certain types of subject lines are working better for you, awesome! Do more of those. If something's not working... well, now you know! Everyone is different, so don’t compare your open rates to industry average or other people; compare only to past you.

Quick & Easy Subject Line Formulas (For When Your Brain Just Can't)

When you're staring at your screen and the words just aren't coming (we've all been there), try these trusty formulas:

1. [Number] Ways to [Solve Problem] Example: "7 ways to write emails people actually open"

2. The "How-To" That Actually Helps Example: "How to write subject lines (without staring at your screen for hours)"

3. Problem + Solution Example: "Tired of low open rates? Here's what changed mine"

Your subject line is like a first impression on a date – you want to be interesting enough to get a second look, but not so over-the-top that you scare them away! 😅

With these tips (and maybe a little trial and error), you'll be writing subject lines that not only get opened but actually help you connect with your subscribers. And isn't that the whole point?